| San Carlos | Mins | New York City FC |
|---|---|---|
| 13" |  Heber | |
| 35" | Heber | |
| 38" |  Heber | |
| J. Aguilar | 45" | |
| 52" | Heber (Pen) | |
 J. Cruz | 53" | |
| C. Acosta | 54" | |
| 61" | A. Callens | |
| 62" | A. Tinnerholm | |
| M. Mena | 63" | |
| 64" | K. Parks | |
| 64" | Heber | |
| 65" | V. Castellanos | |
| Randy Chirino | 70" | |
| M. Mena | 71" | |
| 77" | A. I. Mitrita | |
| O. Browne | 79" | |
| 90" | A. Mitriță |
| San Carlos | New York City FC | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Starting XI | |||
| 18. P. Pemberton | 1. S. Johnson | ||
| 23. J. Smith | 3. A. Tinnerholm | ||
| 12. J. Sánchez | 6. A. Callens | ||
| 28. L. Meza | 4. M. Chanot | ||
| 5. E. Ramírez | 22. R. Matarrita | ||
| 6. C. Acosta | 8. A. Ring | ||
| 4. F. Brenes | 19. J. Medina | ||
| 20. Randy Chirino | 55. K. Parks | ||
| 14. M. Mena | 16. J. Sands | ||
| 7. J. Aguilar | 9. Heber | ||
| 77. J. Cruz | 28. A. Mitriță | ||
| Subs | |||
| 99. O. Browne | 25. J. Scally | ||
| 16. C. Martínez | 10. M. Moralez | ||
| 29. J. Solís | 11. V. Castellanos | ||
| 3. P. Arboine | 33. S. Ibeagha | ||
| 11. R. Cordoba | 17. G. Mackay-Steven | ||
| 1. K. Chamorro | 20. G. Thórarinsson | ||
| 15. G. Méndez | 41. B. Stuver | ||
World CONCACAF Champions League 2020